Wednesday, 13 April 2011

CURRENT DAY THREATS TO CORAL REEFS: NATURE OR NURTURE? (PART 4)


Part 3 looks at the existing and emerging threats to corals reefs as a result of non-climatic anthropogenic factors. Here I review Mulhall (2007) SAVING THE RAINFORESTS OF THE SEA: AN ANALYSIS OF INTERNATIONAL EFFORTs TO CONSERVE CORAL REEFS (PART III A).

The world’s coral reefs are on a downward trajectory. A study in 2004 estimated that since the 1950’s twenty percent of all reefs worldwide had been destroyed, with no chance of recovery, and an additional twenty-four percent of reefs were under imminent threat of collapse. These worldwide declines are a result of numerous causes; they can be global threats (part 1 & 2) whilst others are localised to specific countries and regions (like those discussed below).
Overfishing: Overfishing is a worldwide problem, having wiped out a third of the world’ s fish stocks.  Fishermen are   catching  smaller fish species which are lower down the food chain, not only to make a living but for a rich source of protein and to  ensure they and their families survive. Coral reefs are known for the biodiversity and abundant fish numbers, however over fishing here has many problems. It not only causes harm to  the humans who depend on them for food but also harms  the coral reefs where these fish once lived. Coral reefs have a complex relationship with the fish that live within them. Reefs provide security and habitat for many species of fish and in return herbivorous fish control the abundant algae found in reef environments. Without adequate number of plant-eating fish a reef can become overwhelmed by algae.    
Destructive Fishing: there are two types of fishing practices which not only deplete fish stocks but also damage the reefs themselves:
Blast fishing- involves the use of dynamite to stun and kill the fish which then float to the surface. This method almost certainly guarantees the fisherman a large catch BUT the dynamite kills all marine life in the area including sensitive corals and leaves nothing to replenish fish stocks with.
The use of cyanide :   cyanide is poured into the water around the reefs, stunning tropical fish and allowing for their capture, albeit for the ornamental aquarium fish market or for food. Despite being outlawed in many countries, one million kilograms of cyanide has been illegally used for fishing in the Philippines since the early 1960s. As with blast fishing, cyanide has a devastating impact on surrounding corals and other marine life.    
Pollution: because coral reefs only live in warm environments with abundant sunlight, they are found in shallow waters along the coastline. Unfortunately for coral reefs 40% of the world population also live along these coast lines.  Approximately 80% of all marine pollution now comes from land-based activities, including agricultural, municipal and industrial runoff, agricultural wastes, and atmospheric deposition. Coral reefs’ close proximity to land renders them especially vulnerable to this land based pollution. Agricultural and industrial runoff carries herbicides and other chemicals that harm corals, in addition to excess nutrients that create algae and phytoplankton blooms that suffocate corals. Other types of land-based pollution, such as sewage, wreak havoc on coral reefs as well. In Indonesia, a country located at the centre of the greatest known land and marine biodiversity on the planet, massive migration of the population from rural areas to coastal cities is taking its toll on the country’s reefs. Of all the pollution washing off the land and into the reef systems, untreated sewage is likely the worst. In Jakarta, the capital city, enough untreated sewage is released directly into the bay “to fill seventy-five Olympic-sized swimming pools, each day.” By 1993, one biologist had noted that all the coral reefs in Jakarta Bay were “functionally dead”.
Tourism: When done in the wrong way, tourism associated with coral reefs threatens the very reefs on which the industry depends. The global economics of reef based tourism are huge, (just under 10 billion dollars a year); Australia’s Great Barrier Reef supports a $4.2 billion tourism industries alone, with nearly two million tourists each year.
Irresponsible tourism threatens reefs in a variety of ways: from careless swimmers and divers, to improperly placed boat anchors, to discharges of sewage and other water waste from hotel and resorts. The cruise ship industry is of particular concern for reefs, given the sheer magnitude of the business. Cruise ships regularly “disgorge” throngs of passengers onto coastal reef areas, with around two thousand cruise ship passengers diving in Cozumel, Mexico’s reefs, in any  given day.
Mining: in East Africa Southeast Asia and the Pacific Ocean coral reefs are mined for their large quantities of limestone (calcium carbonate). This limestone can be mixed with sand and water to create cement and be used in the building industry. Alternatively it is used in the pharmaceutical industry to make pills and more recently researchers have mined corals for bone graft clinical trials. Often the corals are mined simply for piece  of dead and living coral which can be used in home as decorations and in jewellery worldwide. 
Invasive Species that are discharged into reef areas from the ballast of ships also pose a threat, especially when no predators or parasites for these introduced species exist in the host reef environment. One of the most noticeably damaging invasive species is the crown-of-thorns starfish of the Great Barrier Reef. This is a voracious coral polyp eater and is increasingly damaging reefs. Declines in predators of this spiny toxic starfish, due to over fishing and pollution have led to population explosions which is currently destroying huge areas of the coral reef.
Other Threats: In addition to those described above coral reefs are threatened by an array of challenges. These include SEDIMENTATION associated with coastal development and deforestation, DREDGING of reefs to create deep water channels and marinas and coral DISEASE. The occurrence of coral disease has increased dramatically in the past ten years, a likely combination of the threats discussed above and in parts 1&2.

CURRENT DAY THREATS TO CORAL REEFS: NATURE OR NURTURE? (PART 3).


Rising Sea Level.

Along with sea temperature increase, ocean acidification corals are also under threat from the rising sea levels associated with climate change. With a predicted sea level rise (of 6cm/ decade) the potential exists for reefs to ‘drown’ (i.e. be covered with such a depth of water that they are below the photic zone or otherwise connect calcify sufficiently to catch up with sea level), but this requires a protracted imbalance between reef accretion rates and sea level rise (Smith & Buddemeier 1992).  
Depending on water clarity and other environmental conditions, the depth range of maximum reef calcification may extend from several metre s to more than 20 metres. This depth range represents a safety factor; transient sea level rise may inundate oceanic reefs to a depth of metre s or even tens of metre s without terminating reef growth if sea levels  rise subsequently returns to a rate less than reef vertical accretion rates. A reef accretion rate of 10 mm/yr is commonly taken as the consensus value for maximum sustained reef vertical accretion rates (Smith & Buddemeier 1992). The predicted for sea level rise over the next century is on average 6 mm/yr (Smith & Buddemeier 1992); this is well within the range of reef accretion rates, and even with no net accretion sea level rise would submerge reefs by less than a metre  by the year 2100.
On the shorter time scale of years to decades, sea level is a changing environmental variable that may interact with other changes and be reflected in organism and community response. Because sea level has been within 1-2 m of its present elevation for several thousand years, many present-day reefs have grown to an elevation where further upward growth is constrained by sea level. Sea level rise can be expected to remove this constraint and result in increases in successful recruitment and coral longevity on intertidal and shallow subtidal reef flats, with a consequent increase in reef flat calcification (Smith & Buddemeier 1992). If rising sea level creates more benign conditions on shallow reefs, diversity and community structure may change as species other than the extremely hardy are able to survive. Increases in coral community diversity and productivity can also be expected in enclosed lagoons where salinity extremes, nutrient depletion, or other aspects of restricted circulation have restricted reef development (Smith & Buddemeier 1992), since the probable effect of rising sea level on circulation will be to maintain reef/lagoon water composition closer to that of the local oceanic water. On the other hand, if deepening water subjects currently sheltered communities to more physical (wave) stress, calcification and sediment accumulation may not increase.
Sea level rise is also strong associated with coral bleaching (Part 1) and associated mortality may selectively remove faster growing taxa, resulting in less rapid CaCO3 accretion and more rapid net removal of framework material by bioerosion.
References
Smith, S.V. & Buddemeier, R.W. 1992. global change and coral reef ecosystems. Annual review of ecological systems. 23: 89-118. 

Saturday, 9 April 2011

CURRENT DAY THREATS TO CORAL REEFS: NATURE OR NURTURE? (PART 2)

A Review of Hoegh-Guldberg et al. (2007) CORAL REEFS UNDER RAPID CLIMATE CHANGE AND OCEAN ACIDIFICATION.

Introduction: Atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration is expected to exceed 500 parts per million and global temperatures to rise by 2 degrees between 2050 and 2100. This significantly exceed conditions of the last 420,000 years during which most extant marine organisms evolved. Under expected conditions for the 21st century, global warming and ocean acidification will compromise carbonate accretion, with corals becoming increasingly rare on reef systems.

What is ocean acidification? During the 20th century, increasing atmospheric CO2 concentrations has driven an increase in the global oceans’ average temperature by 0.74°C, sea level by 17 cm, and has depleted seawater carbonate concentrations and increased acidity by 0.1 pH units. Approximately 25% of the CO2 emitted from all anthropogenic sources currently enters the ocean where it reacts with water to produce carbonic acid. Carbonic acid dissociates to form bicarbonate ions and protons, which in turn react with carbonate ions to produce more bicarbonate ions, reducing the availability of carbonate to biological systems (Fig. 1A). Decreasing carbonate ion concentrations reduce the rate of calcification of marine organisms such as reef-building corals, ultimately favouring erosion.

Figure 1: Links between the buildup of atmospheric CO2 and the slowing of coral calcification due to ocean acidification. 

Modeled scenarios: Hoegh-Guldberg et al. (2007) projected three scenarios for coral reefs over the coming decays and centuries.
1)      375ppc and 1˚C increase (stabilising at the present atmospheric CO2 concentration) coral reefs will continue to change but will remain coral dominated and carbonate accreting in most areas of their current distribution (Fig 2A).
2)      However if we move towards higher CO2 concentrations (450-500ppm and 2˚ increase) coral community compositions will change with some areas becoming dominated by more thermal tolerant corals and others potentially dominated by thermally sensitive but rapidly colonising genera. The density and diversity of corals on reefs are likely to decline leading to vastly reduced complexity and loss of biodiversity including losses of coral associated fish and invertebrates (Fig 2B).
3)      As atmospheric carbon dioxide levels of more than 500ppm are approached levels of carbonate ion concentrations fall well below today’s value and we exhibit an increase of more than 3˚ in sea surface temperature. These changes will reduce coral reef ecosystems to a crumbling frame work with few calcareous corals. Continuously changing climate (which might not stabilise for hundreds of years) is likely to impede migration of corals. Reefs will be rapidly eroded and ultimately become drowned reefs (corals and reef growth fail to keep up with rising sea levels). Under this climate scenario coral reefs become non-functioning (Fig 2C).

Figure 2: Extant reefs from the Great Barrier Reef that are used as analogs for the ecological structures under scenarious 1-3. A). reef slope communities at Heron island. B). mixed algal and coral community  & C). Inshore reef slope.

Impacts: These three scenarios are likely to have serious consequences not only on the corals reefs diversity and density but through wider regional economies e.g. coastal protection, fisheries, and tourism. These consequences become progressively worse as we move through the three potential scenarios.  
 
Conclusion: It is worrying to think that when using the lowest rage of IPCC scenarios there is still devastating effects for coral reefs. At carbon dioxide atmospheric concentration of more than 500 ppm the consequences for coral reefs are extremely risky for both corals and those that depend on them. Climate change also exacerbates local stresses from declining water quality and overexploitation of key species, driving reef increasingly toward the tipping point for functional collapse.

*ppm – parts per million. 

Thursday, 24 March 2011

CURRENT DAY THREATS TO CORAL REEFS: NATURE OR NURTURE?

A Review Of Hoegh-Guldberg  (1999) ‘CLIMATE CHANGE, CORAL BLEACHING AND THE FUTURE OF THE WORLD’S CORAL REEFS’. 

Like all good scientists first they give you the back ground information and only at the very last minute do they draw their conclusions and give you their interesting finds, facts and theories.  So to follow suit here is the background;

Despite corals importance (see future blogs) and their persistence over geological time (previous blogs) corals appear to be one of the most vulnerable marine ecosystems of modem day. Dramatic reversals in their diversity and health have been reported worldwide.  It is estimated that between 50%-70% of all coral reefs are under direct threat from humans (through fishing, deforestation, nutrient enrichment, burning of fossil fuels, and use of toxic chemicals), whilst 100% of coral reefs are exposed indirectly through modifications of interactions with their competitors, predators, pathogens and mutualists. Mass coral ‘bleaching’ is also a major contributing factor to a decline in coral reefs. Since 1979, six major episodes of coral bleaching have occurred (Fig 1), each with associated reef mortality affecting reefs in every part of the world. 

Fig.1. Number of reef provinces bleching since 1979 (from Hoegh-Guldberg 1999)

Whilst reef mortality had started to receive some attention at top levels of world governments there are still many unanswered questions. Houegh-Guldberg (1999) looks at the scientific evidence that suggests coral bleaching is a sign of climate change and builds a case for the prediction that thermally triggered coral bleaching events will increase in frequency and severity in the next few decades. He sets out to answer the following;

1) Is coral bleaching a natural signal that has been misinterpreted as a sign of climate change.   
      2)  Has the incidence of coral bleaching increased since 1979? Or has it simply been over looked prior to 1979?
      3) Are bleaching events likely to increase or decrease in intensity in the next 100 years?


      
Symbiosis in coral reefs: zooxanthellae are intracellular organisms that live within the membrane bound values in the cells of the coral. Studies by Trench and Rowen have revealed that zooxanthellae are a highly diverse group of organism which include 100s of taxa with two or three species per host. Corals benefit from this mutualism by receiving photosynthetic sugars and amino acids, whist in return provide the zooxanthellae  are provide with crucial plant nutrients e.g. ammonia and phosphate from their waste material, with this island of productivity amid this arid desert.

The role of temperature: reefs dominate tropical environments between 30 degrees North and 30 degrees South these roughly coincide of water temperature between 18 degrees and 30 degrees C.  Tropical latitudes further suit corals because seasonal and diurnal fluctuations in tropical sea temperatures are generally very small.  However, Thunnell et al. (1994) suggest sea surface temperatures of the tropical oceans have increased by 2 degrees in that last 18,000 years.  There is a strong correlation between warmer than normal conditions (at least 1 degree higher than a summer maximum) and the incidence of mass coral bleaching.  Increasing water temperature evident rapidly cases zooxanthellae to leave the tissue of reef building corals resulting in a reduced number.  Heat stress does not only cause a reduced population density of zooxanthellae but it also acts to reduces their photosynthetic rate. Basically, light that is essential for high productivity of coral reefs under normal conditions becomes a liability under higher than normal temperatures.  

NOTE: A rise in water temperature is not the sole cause of colour loss and reduced salinity, altered light intensity and exposure to chemicals can all cause corals to become pale, although the physiological response and mechanism by which they do is not the same as true ‘bleaching’.

So why has the incidence of bleaching increased? Some commentators have suggested that it is simply a reflection of the number of observers and the ease with which reports can be made and brought to public attention e.g. by internet.

However, palaeo-sediments have shown that tropical seas have under gone a warming in the past 100 years.  In many tropical seas, rates of change are now greater than 2 degrees per century. By comparing simulated sea temperatures to the thermal thresholds of corals estimates of frequency with which sea surface temperatures will exceed the thermal maximum of corals and their zooxanthellae (Fig 2.).
Fig. 2.Weekly sea surface temperature data for Tahiti, arrows indicate bleaching events in the literature. 
Hoegh-Guldberg (1999) ran fours analysis from three climate change models, which thus stimulate changes in sea temperature.  In all four runs he found (Fig 3);
Fig. 3. Number of times per decade that predicted temperarures exceed coral threshold levels (bleaching events). 
-         The frequency of bleaching is set to rise rapidly, with the rate being highest in the Caribbean and slowest in the Central Pacific.
-         Secondly, the intensity of bleaching will increase at a rate proportional to the probability that the thermal maxima of the corals will be exceeded by future Sea Surface Temperatures.
-         Thirdly, most regions will be experiencing bleaching conditions every year within 30-50 years.
-         Lastly, the reason for the relatively low frequency of bleaching events before 1979 becomes clear; tropical sea temperatures have been rising over the past 100 years (Bijlsma et al. 1995) and have brought corals ever closer to their upper thermal limit. The ability for an El NiƱo event to trigger bleaching was only reached in most oceans in the period from 1970 to 1980. This explains why mass bleaching events are not seen to any great extent before 1979.
It is thought Reef building corals and their zooxanthellae are unable to adapt (genetically) fast enough or acclimatise (phenotypically) to thermal stress. If corals are incapable of changing their physiological response to cope with this stress, bleaching will increase with frequency and intensity with serious consequences.
The acclimatisation of corals and their zooxanthellae refers to the modifications of cellular metabolism which might make them more tolerant to higher temperatures. Whilst adaptation refers to the selection of individual corals within a population that are better able to cope with the new high temperatures and thus survive. Individuals which have a poor affinity to high temperatures either do not survive or do not breed. Acclimatisation can occur over a few hours or days whilst adaptation may require hundreds or thousands of years.

Adaptation: corals and zooxanthellae have variety of thermal optima and maxima across various species. Corals have adapted to local temperatures, this is not surprising since it is universal to all living organisms e.g. the Masi who are adapted to high temperatures and Eskimos adapted to low.  The variation of thermal tolerance suggest that there are genotypes within current coral populations that may be selected for under regimes of increasing temperature. However, this change towards a population dominated by high temperature tolerant genotypes is a slow process and may depend on the stabilization of sea temperatures.

However, the multiple recurrence of bleaching at the same sites over the past 20 years (some coral reefs have bleached during every major bleaching episode) strongly suggests that populations are not rapidly changing their genetic structure to one dominated by more heat-tolerant individuals. A second way that corals might increase their survival is to change their zooxanthellae for more heat-tolerant varieties (Adaptive bleaching hypothesis). Although this idea has attracted much discussion, it is not well supported by evidence.  The observation that corals may have a variety of different types of zooxanthellae in the one colony and experience the selective loss of one type during temperature stress (Rowan et al. 1997) does not necessarily demonstrate that bleaching is adaptive.

Acclimation: Corals and zooxanthellae are able to acclimatise to changes in their environment on a daily or weekly bases e.g. zooxanthellae acclimatize to higher light intensity during the day by modify the concentrations of photoreceptors and associated chemicals.  Despite their ability to acclimatize to changing environmental conditions, reef building corals do not appear to have acclimatized to the rapid increases in sea temperature over the past 20 years. There is no broad pattern suggesting that corals are better at coping when their maximal temperatures are exceeded. Corals seem to be just as close to their thermal limits as they were at the beginning of the 1980s, suggesting that acclimatisation (as well as adaptation) does not seem to have occurred to any great extent. If corals were acclimating (or adapting), then we should see a reduced number of corals affected by bleaching.
Conclusion: Even under moderate greenhouse scenarios (a doubling of current greenhouse gas concentrations by 2100), present and future increases in sea temperature are likely to have severe effects on the worlds coral reefs within 20-30 years. Most coral reef systems are predicted to experiencing near-annual bleaching events that will exceed the extent of the 1998 bleaching event by the year 2040. Some coral reefs (e.g. Caribbean, South-east Asian) will reach this point by 2020. Cooling by anthropogenic aerosols will have little effect on the time that the endpoint is likely to be reached. A better understanding of the capacity for corals and zooxanthellae to adapt to these rapid and on-going changes is required. Present evidence, however, suggests that corals and their zooxanthellae are unable to acclimate or adapt fast enough to keep pace with the present rapid rate of warming of tropical oceans. If the mortality of reef-building corals continues to increase, changes in the distribution of corals will almost certainly occur. Given the central role of corals and zooxanthellae in the structure and function of coral reefs, these changes are likely to have severe and negative effects on the health of coral reefs world-wide by the middle to end of next century. The ecological and economic effects of these changes have not been properly assessed and should be a priority of future research. If, however, the scenario presented in this paper continues to be supported, then a rapid reduction of greenhouse gas emissions over the next decade must be put into effect immediately.
Join me over the weekend for the second instalment of CURRENT DAY THREATS TO CORAL REEFS: NATURE OR NUTURE? Where I will review the atmospheric carbon dioxide.

Reference
Bijlsma, L. Ehler, C. N. Klein, R. J. T. Kulshrestha, S. M. McLean, R. F. Mimura, N., Nicholls, R. J. Nurse, L. A. Perez Nieto, H. Stakhiv, E. Z. Turner, R. K. & Warrick, R. A. 1995. Coastal zones and small islands. In .Climate Change 1995.Impacts, adaptations and mitigations of climate change: scientific-technical analyses: the second assessment report of the Inter-Governmental Panel on Climate Change. (Eds R. T. Watson, M. C. Zinyowera and R. H. Moss.) pp. 6-12. (Cambridge University Press: New York.)
Rowan, R. Knowlton, N. Baker, A. & Jara, J. 1997. Landscape ecology of algal symbionts creates variation in episodes of bleaching. Nature. 388: 265-9.
Thunnell, R. Anderson, D. Gellar, D. & Miao, Q. 1994. Sea-surface temperature estimates for the tropical western Pacific during the last glaciation and their implications for the Pacific warm pool. Quaternery Research. 41: 255-64.

Tuesday, 15 March 2011

ONE CORAL BANK AND HOW A SINGLE 12YR OLD CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE.

Hello, 
Apologies for my lack of blogs over the last 2 weeks: dissertation and poster making seemed to have consumed all my time. Anyway, draft of the dissertation is in and the poster for this course is submitted. Here is a preview of my poster which will be presented on Tuesday, (at least it would be if I could work out how to upload a power point file!  Any suggestions would be more than welcome).
Amid the search for poster material, I came across Reef Quest - established by 12 year old Dylan and now joined by over 6000 people from 23 countries who work to monitor reefs and protect them for the future. Among their work they take their knowledge into schools and communities to emphasize the importance of coral reefs.
One of the tools for doing so is this video which highlights the links between atmosphere, ocean and humans: 
Reef Quest is an excellent example of how one person can help the cause. This is his website.... http://www.reefquest.org/ .... Join the cause!  
On an exciting note, corals have made the news this week - with cryogenic plans getting under way in Australia.
A team of scientists from Taronga Zoo, Australia is working on an ambitious plan to create a 'coral bank' (a bit like a sperm bank).  As the Great Barrier Reef is eroded by global warming, ocean acidification and coral bleaching, embryos will be taken and stored at -296 degrees (Fahrenheit), the temperature of liquid nitrogen. This proposal means the coral reefs could be repopulated from embryos when environmental stresses are reduced. 
'This is really an insurance programme to take the coral out of an uncertain situation and put it in a place that is 100 per cent safe for a very long time' said the zoo's manager of research and conservation, Rebecca Spindler. 
Initial research will concentrate on heat sensitive corals - those most at risk from ocean warming.  If successful, this project could ultimately prevent corals becoming extinct.
See you next week when I will finally give you a comprehensive look into current day threats.

Sunday, 13 March 2011

APOLOGIES: A NEW REVIEW WILL APPEAR SOON.

Sorry about the lack of blogging of late. Dissertation crisis! Come back on Wednesday to see a review of current day threats to the rainforest of the seas.

Friday, 4 March 2011

CORALS IN A CRISIS?

The latest report seems to suggest so ....


http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/feb/23/coral-reef-report-dying-danger


This articles touches on some of the threats to modern day reefs. Join me over the coming weeks to look at these in more detail and see what can be done to save our reefs from extinction.